Great Foundation - but make sure you have an exit plan - Emerging Leaders Program GEICO Employee Review

2.0
Oct 26, 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

- Great place to learn the P&C industry - Excellent learning from management (how to manage but also how NOT to manage) - Exposure to business operations and senior leadership is fantastic - GEICO is on top of their market for a reason. They do a lot of things very well.

Cons

- THE PAY IS AWFUL. Do not let them tell you Profit sharing makes up for this, or that your raises are frequent. They continuously underpay for roles due to 'lack of tenure', but frequently promote you to the next 'grade'. You're perpetually in the cycle of being paid at the bottom of industry band for additional responsibility. - GEICO middle management is overall very lackluster. This becomes much more apparent as you exit to other companies of this size or in the insurance industry. - They focus on so many little things and metrics that don't matter. No one can see the forest from the trees. - Corporate policies were outdated and inflexible - Strategic thinking is limited. Much of the management team blindly follows like sheep, and does little to think outside of the box or understand other successful corporations can run differently than GEICO - Rank and file structure is almost militaristic - They create a culture of mediocrity. Because of the overbearing focus on silly metrics, the associates are constantly burned out - this in turn impacts the supervisors and the management as they're in constant churn to improve the 'metrics' which are causing associate dissatisfaction. GEICO doesn't understand you must drive performance through people, not numbers.

Explore other reviews about GEICO

5.0
Jun 8, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

GEICO is one of the largest employers in my smaller town, so I've heard all the good, the bad, and the ugly. What a pleasant surprise it's been working here! There is so much intentional change to create a great employee experience and get the right team leaders in place. Highly recommend not putting too much weight into older negative comments if you're thinking about applying. I've been very happy with my salary, the benefits/time off, culture, and leadership (both locally and senior leaders). I feel like there's a lot of room to continue to grow my career here and I see the same opportunities for others.

Cons

Really nothing major that I can think of!

2.0
Jun 26, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Interesting problems to work on. Good benefits. Decent pay.

Cons

Managers will gaslight you and upper leadership is constantly changing, so expect projects you're working on to be thrown out every 6 months. Many people burn out and quit after some time and are never back filled, so you'll be expected to take on their workload. Some of my colleagues were working 80 hour work weeks to keep up with the work load and yet told they were not performing well enough. There also wasn't much diversity.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All