Major growing pains... - Anonymous employee Indeed Employee Review

3.0
Jul 15, 2018
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

* Great people * Nice perks and employee benefits * Generous 401K matching program * Happy hours and company events * Unlimited PTO (at your manager's digression) While I have a lot of constructive criticism below, my experience at Indeed was invaluable. I learned a lot about the industry, gained a majority of my professional experience, had a good amount of professional training that was offered by the company and made some wonderful lifelong friendships. My feedback below is in hopes to help make Indeed stronger in areas that I would love to see them improve on for the sake of their current employees and the overall success of the company.

Cons

I joined Indeed several years ago when it was not a well known company. Understanding that as a company has significant growth, it's going to change, I am still saddened by the direction Indeed is headed. There are many reasons Indeed is a strong competitor in this industry; primarily being it's large share of traffic compared to it's competitors. I always loved sharing with my customers the many perks Indeed offers for free over it's competitors. However, in the past year or two, I've seen Indeed take the wonderful perks and monetize them. In addition, it seems that Indeed is also starting to use some of the pricing models as our competitors. While I understand some of the reasoning behind it, I feel like there are drastic changes that are so far from what Indeed was as a company and what we always said set us apart from our competitors. Indeed always had two core products, resume and job for many years. In the past few years, they've rolled out so many product to dominate the market. However, this fast progression is concerning when things are rolled out too early, leaving customers unhappy and your support teams having to be the face of the company in messy situations. I would love to see Indeed hire more experienced talent to help build a stronger foundation. Most of the higher level employees are in their positions because of the length of time they've been with the company, having luck with being in the right place at the right time, or due to favoritism. I think the company, especially the San Mateo office, can use a stronger foundation in hopes that this will help with retention. The turnover rate is extremely high which can be disheartening to a team when it's constantly losing team members. There seems to be a continuous cycle of team members leaving, causing the rest of the team to have a heavy workload while managers frantically try to hire quickly and train a new hire to help lessen the workload while their team is drowning. At some points in my career at Indeed, it became embarrassing to take on an account from someone who had left and introduce myself to a customer knowing they had probably gone through several CS members in a short period of time while we were back-filling the former rep's position. I would also like to take the time to acknowledge the CS teams in San Mateo. While most are young - I would say that a majority of them work their butts off to do the best with whatever situation they're put in. My wonderful team members are what kept me at Indeed for as long as I did and was the sole reason that made it hard for me to leave. I would love to see the company make changes to their compensation. Especially for the Bay Area, Indeed is not competitive. We are constantly told that Indeed does market research and their compensation levels are competitive. I just don't see how this can be true. While they once used to negotiate salaries, it seems that starting a couple years ago they moved to a model where if you are going for X role, you can only make up to $X. One of the reasons I chose to leave was due to compensation. After being promoted a few times, I knew that based on their new salary model, I was already making above what the promoted role would offer - therefore, I really couldn't make any more money at Indeed. I know this because I saw this happen to many of my tenured colleagues. I think this may have changed shortly after I left, but it's hard to see them lose top talent by not being flexible and taking into consideration your experience and how much it would cost to have to hire externally, train someone and get them up to speed. I don't see how that can be cost efficient, especially when you're losing top talent with a significant knowledge base that is truly priceless.

avatar
Indeed Response
7y
Thank you for your review of working at Indeed. We really appreciate you taking the time to give us feedback as we’re always looking to improve as a business. As the company has grown we have had to evolve our product offerings and pricing models to keep pace with that growth. We still believe that what we offer employers is different and unique to what other online recruitment tools can provide. In regards to rewarding our employees, we research compensation in each market where we compete for talent, and have a dedicated benefits team that are continually adjusting levels based on data and feedback. Thank you again for your review. We are listening, and we value the time you have taken to share.

Explore other reviews about Indeed

5.0
Jun 2, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Good total comp in my opinion

Cons

None that I can think of

4.0
Jun 3, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

I loved the talented people I worked with; I appreciated being appreciated; I loved helping employers hire; and I really thought this would be the company I retired from.

Cons

The company culture changed significantly after it became publicly traded; I didn't particularly care for how they handled layoffs; they didn't always act on the feedback they received; and they were slow to jump on the AI train.

1
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All