Skip to contentSkip to footer
  • Community
  • Jobs
  • Companies
  • Salaries
  • For employers
      Notifications

      Loading...

      Elevate your career

      Discover your earning potential, land dream jobs, and share work-life insights anonymously.

      employer cover photo
      employer logo
      employer logo

      Selective Insurance

      Engaged employer

      About
      Reviews
      Pay and benefits
      Jobs
      Interviews
      Interviews
      Related searches: Selective Insurance reviews | Selective Insurance jobs | Selective Insurance salaries | Selective Insurance benefits
      Selective Insurance interviewsSelective Insurance Underwriter interviewsSelective Insurance interview


      Glassdoor

      • About / Press
      • Awards
      • Blog
      • Research
      • Contact Us
      • Guides

      Employers

      • Free Employer Account
      • Employer Centre
      • Employers Blog

      Information

      • Help
      • Guidelines
      • Terms of Use
      • Privacy and Ad Choices
      • Do Not Sell Or Share My Information
      • Cookie Consent Tool
      • Security

      Work With Us

      • Advertisers
      • Careers
      Download the App

      • Browse by:
      • Companies
      • Jobs
      • Locations
      • Communities
      • Recent posts

      Copyright © 2008-2026. Glassdoor LLC. "Glassdoor," "Worklife Pro," "Bowls" and logo are proprietary trademarks of Glassdoor LLC.

      Company Bowl sample

      Want the inside scoop on your own company?

      Check out your Company Bowl for anonymous work chats.

      Bowls

      Get actionable career advice tailored to you by joining more bowls.

      Followed companies

      Stay ahead in opportunities and insider tips by following your dream companies.

      Job searches

      Get personalised job recommendations and updates by starting your searches.

      Underwriter Interview

      Mar 4, 2025
      Anonymous employee
      Indianapolis, IN
      Accepted offer
      Positive experience
      Easy interview

      Application

      I applied through other source. The process took 2 weeks. I interviewed at Selective Insurance (Indianapolis, IN) in Jul 2024

      Interview

      Straightforward and not a lot of pressure. Very flexible with interviewing remotely. There were multiple interviews but everyone made the process easy. Spoke with HR first, next two interviews were with managers and other Underwriters.

      Interview questions [1]

      Question 1

      How would you describe yourself as an underwriter?
      Answer question

      Other Underwriter interview reviews for Selective Insurance

      Underwriter Interview

      Jun 7, 2025
      Anonymous interview candidate
      Newark, NJ
      No offer
      Negative experience
      Average interview

      Application

      I applied through other source. The process took 4 weeks. I interviewed at Selective Insurance (Newark, NJ) in Apr 2025

      Interview

      They ghosted me after two interviews. I reached out multiple times, including through LinkedIn. I'm okay if they didn't extend an offer, but at least they could have informed me. Not getting back to me after two interviews tells me a lot about this company.

      Interview questions [1]

      Question 1

      Tell me about your self
      Answer question

      Underwriter Interview

      Jul 28, 2020
      Anonymous employee
      Accepted offer
      Negative experience

      Application

      I interviewed at Selective Insurance

      Interview

      Way too long of a process. Seriously, way too long. Minimally 15 interviews with 15 people. Like, is this NASA or the Secret Service? Why all the travel doe interviews too?

      Interview questions [1]

      Question 1

      Why they are super awesome...i did not have a clue
      Answer question
      3

      Top companies for "Compensation and Benefits" near you

      avatar
      Sun Life
      3.8★Compensation and benefits
      avatar
      Intact
      3.8★Compensation and benefits
      avatar
      Travelers
      4.1★Compensation and benefits
      avatar
      Co-operators
      3.5★Compensation and benefits