Pros
Decent starting wage if you're MAP (non-specialist MA). Decent management if you're in NCS - good company direction and changes.
Cons
Lately, Singtel's Glassdoor reviews have been bombarded with negative feedback about the MA program, particularly concerning the management and the company as a whole. The entire cohort of Year 1 and Year 2 MAs were then gathered for a town hall to address these concerns. Despite this, the real problems remain unaddressed. I want to share my two cents on the operations of the MAP in general, for fresh graduates looking for new opportunities, and for the senior executives at Singtel who are making the decisions.
Let's face it, if a proper feedback system were implemented and the concerns of MAs were adequately addressed, the Glassdoor incident would have been reduced to an email requesting suggestions. An MA, supposedly an elite new hire given extra care and resources, wouldn't feel the need to write a manifesto and create several Glassdoor accounts to bash Singtel. When this happens, it's pretty clear that something is seriously wrong with the company.
To put it simply, MAs aren't given enough attention. In most MNCs, there are around 6-8 MAs per region at most. In Singtel, it's 60. With two cohorts, that means 120 people. These 120 future leaders are given only two P&Cs (HR) to host MA events and handle their logistics. And if you plan to increase the intake even further, how are you going to convince these young professionals that their offer is harder to get than admission to Harvard when you barely provide any support for each of them? You keep feeding their egos by saying how precious this opportunity is and how much exposure they will get, yet there are barely any meaningful training opportunities provided. There is no point in having 180 choices when most managers and roles are not suited for MAs. Many roles are traps that do not offer any exposure or management insights. The only insight they offer is how little the company cares about ensuring a meaningful learning journey for MAs.
Moreover, this year's rotation was horrendous. Some managers had their roles cancelled out of the blue despite MAs having already selected their choices. Some MAs were informed not to reach out to those managers and received no role assignments. Many were rejected by all three choices and had to cold-call managers to hire them. This is absolutely unacceptable. We were never given any explanation other than excuses for what happened this year.
It is a known fact that the retention rate for MAs is really low, and many have already left mid-program for other opportunities. Knowing this for years, Singtel's solution has been to increase the intake. This is like trying to fill a leaky bucket by pouring in more water instead of fixing the holes. Come on, Singtel, you have the money and budget. If you want actual loyal hires, hear me out: Decrease the intake to 10 people or less, no more than that. Trust me, I know it's scary to hire less than two school buses of kids. But the decrease in number means more care and resources. Give them at least $8k per person and up to 6 months of bonuses, and fire the person with the lowest rating every year. Provide meaningful rewards for their hard work. Offer meaningful training about the structure and management of the company, not just MBTI in colours. They are supposed to be elites, not just two classes of flashy, cocky teens with the "management" tag. Let them make decisions, put them in management meetings, and most importantly, give them a feedback channel. There is no better feedback a company can get than from a pair of fresh eyes that actually care about the institution. I like this program, I met some amazing people during my journey and I honestly think it has a lot of potential. If we want to empower a new generation, there is a lot of work to be done. Let's start by taking the first step.