RISE Against the Machine - Director Sortly Employee Review

1.0
Sep 30, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Redefine success: Sortly is unlike other opportunities - it's a rare chance to help build a company in reverse and define success as something more than numbers, by creating an authentic, inclusive culture worth celebrating. Bring clarity: Where others see chaos, you can chart the path forward, establish transparent processes, and create focus for future employees. Shape identity: Decode the history and decisions embedded in the product and strategy, then help craft a clear, shared identity that employees can rally around. Build strong foundations: Lay down documentation, processes, and institutional memory so that both remote-first and in-office teams can thrive with continuity and confidence. Co-create culture: Replace boilerplate programs with genuine human connection, break silos, and foster a culture rooted in inclusion, psychological safety, and shared wins. Champion growth: Design support systems that transform burnout and quiet exits into opportunities for retention, recognition, and career development. Design the future of work: Build a model where AI augments creativity rather than replaces it, supporting sustainable growth and human-centered innovation. Leave a legacy: Contribute more than features - leave artifacts, practices, and lessons that strengthen culture and inspire future employees. Share your experience: If patterns repeat, add your perspective on Glassdoor to help Sortly evolve into the company it aspires to be.

Cons

Advice: Sortly is over a decade old, but unlike many companies its age, it operates in unique ways. Do twice the research and ask questions you wouldn't ask other companies- it's important to read between the lines. Outsourced origins: Much of the early product, brand, and strategy was shaped by agencies and contractors. While this provided a good starting point, it can feel like the company is still learning how to grow and sustain these functions internally. Single-founder dynamics: Without co-founders to balance the load, alignment and long-term structure can feel fragmented, and functions may drift into isolation. Fractional leadership: Part-time executive presence slows decision-making, creates gaps in clarity, and makes it harder to align around a cohesive, inclusive vision. Employee turnover: Churn can feel high, eroding continuity and forcing teams to continually rebuild context and knowledge. Lack of reflection: Retrospectives and post-mortems are rare, so recurring issues often go unaddressed, draining momentum. Decision-making gaps: Some problems are acknowledged but often left unresolved, leaving teams uncertain about priorities. Disconnected leadership: Hard decisions are sometimes deferred to executives or outside consultants who feel distant from the day-to-day, resulting in transactional choices. Metrics-first mindset: KPIs, survey scores, and revenue often outweigh fulfillment, innovation, or cultural initiatives. Product-practice gap: Industry-standard inventory practices and terminology are not always fully embraced, leading to strategies or features that feel out of sync with customer expectations. Would advise asking questions about Sortly's blog in interviews. Shallow prioritization: Foundational features may be deprioritized (e.g., sorting table columns), while AI initiatives are seen as must-haves. Formulaic culture efforts: HR programs and RISE messaging can feel generic and top-down, sometimes outsourcing external agencies to run events - which may feel less authentic than employee-driven initiatives. Limited psychological safety: Communication about departures is often minimal, leaving employees to hear of changes indirectly, which creates unease, uncertainty, and can erode trust. Knowledge gaps: Documentation is thin and communication fragmented, so challenges resurface, alignment is lost, and remote-first collaboration requires more meetings than necessary.

avatar
Sortly Response
7mo
Thanks for taking the time to share your detailed feedback. We recognize that everyone’s experience at Sortly is unique, and we appreciate the insights you’ve offered. Feedback helps us continue to evolve, strengthen our culture, and create an environment where people can do meaningful work. We appreciate your past contributions and wish you continued success in your journey.

Explore other reviews about Sortly

5.0
Dec 11, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

- Ample amount of growth opportunities - Empathetic and approachable culture and upper management - Clear communication and goals - Competitive pay - Remote work - Intelligent colleagues

Cons

If you don't have a learning and growth appetite then this place might not be for you.

avatar
Sortly Response
4mo
Thank you for taking the time to share this thoughtful review! We’re really glad to hear that you’re experiencing clear goals, transparent communication, and a supportive, empathetic culture as those are things we work hard to build and protect as we continue to grow. We especially appreciate your callout around learning and growth. We aim to foster an environment for people who are curious, motivated, and excited to keep improving, and it’s great to hear that this comes through in your experience.
1.0
May 14, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

I developed some great working relationships with many of my cross-functional peers. There are some truly smart people working at Sortly who are great at what they do and are also kind, to boot. Many of them reached out to me after I left and offered their support, which says a lot about them. They also offer a fairly decent benefits package, the ability to be fully remote, and year-end week-long closure between Christmas and New Years’ Day for employees to recharge. The CEO is also a friendly and very approachable person. I really enjoyed all my conversations and interactions with him during company offsites.

Cons

In my opinion, management does not provide adequate support to people who have special learning and executive function needs due to neurodivergence. The first 6 months of my tenure were some of the best I’ve ever had in my career, and I had a lot of autonomy and ownership that helped me thrive as the only person in my function after the manager who hired me left 3 months after I started. The freedom to execute and drive projects helped me perform well and resulted in a great rating during my quarterly review. The company went into a hyper-growth stage in late 2025 with lots of hiring, and after that, something changed. I went from feeling great about my contributions and like I was a valued teammate to feeling like no matter how hard I worked, I wouldn’t live up to my manager’s expectations. I disclosed a disability earlier in the year and asked for reasonable accommodations after receiving additional medical testing to find out more information about it and learn how I could best perform given some of my issues. That is where I felt things really went south. Not a single accommodation I asked for would have cost the company any money, but it felt like they were not something my manager was really invested in working with me on. It was surprising, because I thought we had a great relationship up to that point. All I asked for to help me succeed was better clarity. Crystal-clear expectations, documented (the documented part is key here) goals, and to be held to a standard that was easily understandable, consistently applied, and not vague. Instead, my work was micro-scrutinized, making me feel less confident and like I lost ownership over it. I was given three areas to improve upon and one month to improve after my one-year performance review, but was not told specifically how those areas would be measured. Nearing the end of the month, I had only one deliverable in progress because there was nothing else new in my pipeline, So I raised concerns about how the one-month review of my progress could be evaluated fairly, because there was also no formally documented PIP. Rather than talk with me and address my concerns, my manager’s response was to coldly terminate my employment. My takeaway from my own experience at Sortly is that there’s no time for anyone who rocks the boat or needs extra help, even if they have a federally protected disability. I luckily sensed there was a problem and kept receipts. I’ve also filed a complaint with the EEOC and am currently seeking legal counsel regarding how I was treated, because I sincerely believe neurodivergent individuals deserve a chance to be successful and in my case, I feel like Sortly did not allow me that chance. Invisible disabilities are still disabilities and not something to be swept under the table. All in all, I felt like my experience completely flew in the face of the company’s principles. And the irony isn’t lost on me that pictures of me are on their brand new Careers page at a time when I would never recommend Sortly to anyone I know.

avatar
Sortly Response
3w
Thanks for taking the time to share this feedback. Sortly is committed to providing reasonable accommodations to employees in accordance with applicable legal requirements, and we take this kind of feedback seriously. Sortly prides itself on a work environment where every employee feels seen, supported, and set up to succeed, and are disappointed to hear that your experience did not align with the inclusive and welcoming culture we have worked hard to build. We're not able to speak to individual employment situations in a public forum. However, we welcome the opportunity to discuss this matter with you directly. Please reach out to the People Operations team.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All