Okay place to start, not a good idea to stay longer than a year or two. - Anonymous employee NJM Insurance Employee Review

2.0
Jul 27, 2019
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Training is excellent! Free coffee, soup, iced tea, and milk in the cafeteria. Good place to gain experience then leave.

Cons

Unfortunately the cons list is much longer than the pros list. Benefits provided are only health, life, and dental and you need to pay a portion of it. Upon interviewing with other companies, I found most offer these benefits in full without you needing to pay a portion. Pay is much lower than a lot of other upstanding insurance companies in the area, about 7k-10k lower. There is absolutely no work/life balance what so ever for the representatives or underwriters in the personal lines department. They provide PTO but its highly restricted on how and when you can use it. They make you request off the days you need almost a year plus in advance. If something comes up during the year and you have to take off or need to leave early, forget about it. They do not assist their employees in career development. I once asked for additional responsibilities/ things that can be done off the phones and was basically told it was my job to answer phones. After that I started seeking employment with a better company because my talents were not valued and I did not appreciate being told I was basically just an answering machine for the customers that call in. Some reps have been doing the same job for 10 years plus with little recognition and no advancement which makes it a very depressing place to work. Recently they created new job titles within the same positions which makes it confusing as to where everyone stands. Also creates false hope for a lot of those people because not all of them will be promoted. On top of the bad work environment the company constantly has rate increases so the customers are generally very unhappy when they call in. Overall a very stressful job with tons of responsibility and not enough pay.

Explore other reviews about NJM Insurance

5.0
Oct 22, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great department and work life balance

Cons

No options of full time work from home

1
2.0
May 26, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Good pay, Good benefits, Cheap lunch.

Cons

No downtime, Very small PSL,Every two weeks calls are listened and critized nothing is perfect for them.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All