employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Utica National Insurance Group

Engaged employer

Do not recommend - Manager Utica National Insurance Group Employee Review

2.0
Dec 14, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Remote Seasoned staff Not micromanaged

Cons

So while you may not be micromanaged, you are also not managed or guided. My director lacked the ability to lead at that level. Often not understanding that there are better more efficient ways to manage claims. If they want to remain status quo they need to only hire from within. The approval process for larger claims is horrendous, sometimes stretching for 30 days or more, and if someone in the chain was out of office it just stopped. One time the CEO was out of the office so a large approval sat there for 35 days. Making request for large payments is an email string, thats it. You are supposed to keep track of email strings for millions upon millions of dollars on a claim because senior leadership above director level wont put notes in the file. Also, if you get called or asked a question on a request you made 15 days ago you are supposed to remember at the drop of a hat what the exact request was for. There is no real standard for how larger claims should be handled--there are basic guidelines yes. But what you did and the expert you used one claim is not the same process on the next and how dare you not know. Such as, a verbal IA recommendation with a short report is good to post reserves on one claim, then a similar claim "why didn't you get a ROM" well we never asked for one before... No room to grow. Everything is attorney run. Many people talk about the culture, but I found it extremely dry and cold, noone is approachable, you cant get people on the phone to talk to you. Even HR is unapproachable and very quick to pull the "fire" card. Also, terminations are heavy in Q4---convenient as reviews and salary increases and bonus are the first quarter of the following year.

Explore other reviews about Utica National Insurance Group

5.0
Jun 23, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great leadership, benefits and culture. Utica rewards hard work, but also offers a work life balance.

Cons

I have been here less then a year, but cannot think of any negatives.

5.0
Jun 23, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great work life balance, Manageable pending, Great benefits, Generous PTO, The interview process was efficient and straightforward, and the recruiter was extremely helpful, maintaining clear communication with me every step of the way. This company is very thoughtful in its approach to onboarding, taking the time to ensure employees are set up to succeed rather than being overwhelmed with an excessive workload. I truly feel valued here and don’t feel like just a number.

Cons

I can not list any cons.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All