Problems start at the very top; turnover speaks for itself - Anonymous employee STIR Employee Review

1.0
Apr 20, 2016
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

- Benefits could be worse. - Initially there can be a good amount of autonomy to work directly with clients on interesting projects.

Cons

- No employee guidebook and no policies spelled out. If you're coming from somewhere corporate with a lot of red tape, this may not sound so bad, but in practice it's a nightmare. Each department is treated differently, and some appear to be granted more flexibility than others when it comes to time off, leaving early for appointments, dipping out for three-hour lunches, etc. It has created insurmountable resentment among the whole team. It is discouraged to work from home under any circumstance, including sickness, which routinely leads to sick people dragging themselves into the office and infecting the rest. Management will make fun of you for "being sick all the time" if you miss a couple of days due to illness. It's clear that the priority is productivity and the bottom line; never the employee's health or well being (which obviously impacts the bottom line when employees can't perform at their best, but nobody seems to put two and two together). If you need to leave for a family emergency or funeral, don't expect any understanding from top management (and don't expect any time off, because this is the only employer I've ever known that doesn't give bereavement days). - Management provides criticism that's destructive, not constructive. Even if you have a great direct supervisor, his or her hands will be tied when it comes to advocating for you. If you aren't on the short list of the management's current favorites, you're toast. No room for growth or promotion. The management technique at the top is to both publicly and privately criticize employees. It happens to everyone, so don't take it personally, and also try not to internalize it; chances are you're not an idiot or terrible at your job, but you're working in a place where people are torn down rather than built up. It can take its toll after a while. The exception is for new employees, who often enjoy a short honeymoon period where they are praised and celebrated for their work. This period is generally short-lived. - Some people in the agency like to harken back to the "Mad Men" days, and not in a good way. It's 2016, yet flagrant displays of sexism, racism and homophobia in the workplace are all too common. It extends beyond bad jokes and spills over into the way people are treated. Conservative politics are regularly and openly discussed. It's the only workplace I've known in which people have such little decorum when it came to how to behave in a professional environment--and again, it all starts at the top.

Explore other reviews about STIR

5.0
Jul 21, 2016
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Autonomous work environment Ability to take on different roles Flexible

Cons

Structure of a small company sometimes leads to ambiguity of tasks

5.0
Apr 21, 2016
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

STIR is a great agency, not only for a job in the ad industry but also to advance your career. The management hires talented people who want to make a difference and "own" their work. This is key because you don't find this at many other agencies. STIR is smaller than some other agencies in Milwaukee (I believe they are around 30 people) but I've found this to be an advantage because the agency, and those conducting the work, can be more swift to engage with clients and their clients work. This also opens the door for you as an employee to take the lead on more projects and grow in your role. The creative output from STIR is fantastic and there is an integrated approach mentality across the departments. Employees work hard and play hard. Everyone generally likes working with one another. Compensation and benefits was above average. I believe you start with two weeks vacation but that could be negotiated. There's always drinking to be done on Friday's and when new biz wins are announced. If you value a relaxed atmosphere, trust in your role and offering, mentorship, fun and exciting work - then this an agency for you.

Cons

Not many to list here. Just as there are with any agency, there were some small growing pains. Outlining digital processes and utilizing some external vendors was sometimes a challenge.

5
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All