Be The Change - Anonymous employee Pie Insurance Employee Review

5.0
Jun 4, 2018
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

You know the phrase, Be The Change? If you want to Be The Change, work at Pie. Pie offers an incredibly unique opportunity for our team to disrupt a dinosaur of an industry while creating a company that we want to work for. It takes an incredible amount of courage, commitment and hard work to stand up an insurance company in less than a year. It's all about the team. Big picture, being part of something so revolutionary is an incredible career experience. It gives meaning to your work, even the most mundane tasks, which are inevitable and frequent in a small startup environment. We are a meritocracy. It doesn't matter what you did at your last job or whether you have 20 years of experience doing X. The best idea can come from the person with the least experience. It has to be the best idea, though, and it has to do right by our customers and our team members. Given how small we are, the benefits are quite good. I gave 5 stars given the size and age of our company. Pie pays for 100% of the insurance premiums for its team members. That's right - 100% Pie paid. We also offer a take-what-you-need time off policy. And, most importantly, every team member gets a piece of Pie, literally, in the form of stock options. Adult environment. I work 8-10 hours most days. We aren't on the clock - people get the work done, and that's what matters. Team members arrive between 8:30 and 10 AM. It's not the kind of place where you get written up for coming in late. What matters is that you handle your business in a mature, thoughtful way while supporting the team. Flexible dress. Really cool DC office in a co-working space. Looks like a West Elm catalog in here! Awesome amenities - relaxation room is a nice place to chill out. Beer on tap. Walking distance to great restaurants and multiple Metro lines. All lines are within walking distance, actually. The Denver office is also in a very modern, brand-new space at Industry RiNo. Sit/stand desks, gorgeous outdoor lounge. One stop from Union Station and (for now) free parking.

Cons

Don't come here for glamour or power. Expect to get your hands dirty and work hard. It's a fast pace. You have to fail fast, pick yourself up, dust it off and keep going. Sometimes, the pace and the failure can feel awfully uncomfortable. To us, that's part of the path to success. But, it's uncomfortable, especially if you've worked in a larger, more structured company. High degree of ambiguity. We're a young company (founded in 2017), we're laser focused on building the business. If you thrive in detailed project plans and tons of documented processes, well, we just aren't there yet. It's important for people to select an environment that works for them, so we tend to look for people who don't need a lot of structure to thrive. Risk. There's a degree of risk in every startup. We had a great seed round raise, and the market response to our product has been fantastic. Our co-founders are no spring chickens; they're experienced leaders with industry experience. But, this environment is not for the risk-averse.

avatar
Pie Insurance Response
7y
Thank you for your kind words. We really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience here at Pie. We count ourselves lucky to have Pie-oneers like you! -The People Team @ Pie

Explore other reviews about Pie Insurance

5.0
Oct 23, 2025
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Pie is mission-driven and focused on modernizing an outdated industry, giving employees the chance to build products that genuinely help small businesses. The organization embraces modern technology and design thinking, encouraging innovation, experimentation, and new ideas. Leadership is accessible and human, and the company invests in connection and community even in a remote environment.

Cons

Because Pie is growing fast, change is constant—if you need rigid structure or slow, steady routines, it may feel overwhelming at times.

2
3.0
May 26, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

I worked with many talented, thoughtful engineers who cared about building reliable systems and supporting each other. The remote environment was generally workable, and there were meaningful technical problems to solve across backend services, APIs, data quality, production support, and customer-facing workflows. I also appreciated opportunities to take ownership, mentor teammates, and work on systems that had real operational impact.

Cons

Priorities and organizational direction could shift quickly, which sometimes made it harder to plan long-term technical work or understand how career growth would be evaluated. Communication around larger company changes could have been clearer and more timely. Career progression, role expectations, and decision-making sometimes felt uneven across teams.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All