employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Engaged employer

Dismal and a Waste of Time! After a 90 day hiring process, the over abundance of work and micro managing began. - Anonymous employee Philadelphia Insurance Companies Employee Review

1.0
Aug 31, 2014
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The only good thing about PHLY is the amount of money this company donates to charities. If you happen to have a good supervisor or manager; and depending on where you live; you may have an opportunity to telecommute the majority of the time; or part time. This depends on how much "butt" you kiss; or your prior relationship with your supervisor prior to being employed with PHLY. PHLY does a lot of community activities and volunteer work to continue to gain a presence on the "top places to work list"; but on the inside. The work place is anything but happy or gleeful. It's a dismal place, that make grave yards look comforting.

Cons

I have to say that the management and HR Staff are a joke and completely disappointing. The only thing that they appear to do right is micro manage, and refusing to address the real issues and concerns at hand. The work load is 3-4 times MORE than the industry standard; for about 20% or more LESS pay. I never seen so many unhappy people in one company. That should have been my clue when I first started...no one was happy, but they were too afraid to leave due to health benefits or other reasons. Most of the management appears to have no integrity and take a dictatorship towards management. Unlike most insurance companies who have a call center; PHLY does not. They expect the assistants to not only assist the examiners, and the managers, but also to answer phones all while completing their daily tasks. Puts undue stress on the entire staff. Even though PHLY states that they have a team approach; its every person for themselves. There is definitely NO ROOM FOR ADVANCEMENT, and you have to beg for the 2% year raise. That is...if they do not tell you that you are at the maximum pay for your position. We have experienced an extreme amount of turn over with employees quitting often, and then the staff is worked even harder, while management swears it takes a half a year to fill the position with a qualified applicant (If they EVEN fill the position). They have a yearly review which is completely based on your manager's view of you, and a metric based results. If management has personal reasons for not liking you...you can kiss a good review good bye. Your manager can rate you; but there is no way to rate management or upper management. If you complain to HR; just know that your concerns and issues will fall on death ears. You are just another employee and they treat you like you are a temp. Marketing and Underwriting are considered the cream of the organization; and claims personnel are the black sheep of the organization.

Explore other reviews about Philadelphia Insurance Companies

5.0
Jun 5, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Flexibility with a hybrid work schedule. Ability to learn more products, so it can be challenging but fun if you are looking for growth. Metrics and everyone knows what to expect which seems to be industry standard across small business.

Cons

None. PTO comparative seems light as you start out.

3.0
Feb 9, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Nice people, focus on technology, upper management is usually ahead of insurance trends, immediate supervisors were nice and well meaning. Benefits are good, not great. Good amount of PTO.

Cons

In small business unit, you have monthly quotas and managers are constantly asking how much you are quoting and if you will reach that number. Various levels of punishment if you don’t hit this number. Quality of work, risk selection, accuracy doesn’t really matter, only how much you quote. There is no positive in hitting this number beyond not being bothered until the next month. If you exceed this number consistently, you’ll just be asked to do more. Company is doing everything in its power to save expenses. The pay rate is well below the market. People consistently leave and make much more money elsewhere. Most lower level jobs are being shipped to an Indian company and even the Indian company is having job functions replaced by AI. This is usually at the expense of quality or what our agents actually want. CEOs preach saving expenses and not replacing people, as they show up to your office after flying in a private jet and a car service. Finally, 90% of the people in the region I worked were related to somebody who either works there, were their friends, or were related to agents we did business with. Some of these people had positions made for them, where they sat there and studied for 6 months, instead of promoting people from within. This will also prevent job mobility.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All