Declining culture and inconsistent leadership - Manager Michelman Employee Review

2.0
Dec 15, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

* Good benefits compared to similar companies. * Work itself can be interesting if you’re in a technical or operational role. * Some knowledgeable and hardworking employees, especially at the plant and operational levels

Cons

Michelman is a third-generation family company, but since the current leadership took over, the culture has gone downhill. It feels like the company has lost its direction, and a lot of the values it used to talk about no longer show up in how people are actually treated. At the plant level, people are let go for things that used to be handled with coaching or common sense. Speaking up, questioning changes, or pushing back in any way puts a target on your back. Because of that, most employees keep their heads down and say as little as possible. Honest feedback isn’t encouraged, it’s risky. Leadership above the plant is weak and inconsistent. Expectations change depending on who you talk to, decisions get delayed or avoided, and accountability is unclear. Teams end up working against each other instead of together, mostly because no one wants to be blamed when something goes wrong. The tone from senior leadership doesn’t help, especially at the VP level. Interactions are often dismissive and condescending, and people are talked to in ways that would never be acceptable in a healthy organization. That behavior sets the tone for everyone else and makes it clear that respect isn’t a priority. There’s also a big focus on optics instead of real execution. A lot of energy goes into appearances — trade shows, messaging, and looking good on paper — while day-to-day issues are ignored. There’s a remote group that gets plenty of visibility but seems largely disconnected from the actual work. They contribute very little on a daily basis, yet face almost no scrutiny, while plant and operational teams are constantly under pressure. The lack of consistent accountability is obvious. Raising concerns rarely leads to anything changing. Issues get acknowledged, but nothing happens, and the same problems keep coming back. Over time, people stop trying. You can see the impact now. Morale is low, good people keep leaving, and the business is struggling. Instead of dealing with the real problems, leadership seems more focused on control and protecting the company’s image. Unless there’s a real change in leadership behavior and accountability, Michelman will continue to lose talent and damage its reputation from the inside out.

avatar
Michelman Response
2mo
Thank you for sharing this candid feedback and for your many years at Michelman. We take concerns around culture, leadership consistency, accountability, and psychological safety seriously. When expectations, behaviors, or decision‑making lack clarity or consistency, it impacts trust and engagement, and that is not acceptable. These themes are actively under review as we work to strengthen leadership effectiveness, listening, and accountability across the organization. We appreciate the perspective and recognize our responsibility to turn feedback like this into meaningful action.

Explore other reviews about Michelman

5.0
Oct 24, 2025
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Incredible benefits, work-life balance, & meaningful work are the headliners here. Co-workers have a genuine care for each other and their families. Family-owned business give a nice flavor to the culture that makes everything feel personable & approachable.

Cons

Some of the senior management had leadership styles that alienated those on their teams & adjacent departments. In terms of career progression, it is a very flat organization structure which while allowing for a wide range of responsibilities in each role, there isn't a lot of upward mobility & promotions within departments.

avatar
Michelman Response
5mo
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and for being part of the Michelman team for several years. We’re thrilled to hear that you value our benefits, work-life balance, and the meaningful nature of the work we do. It’s also great to know that our family-owned culture and the care among colleagues resonate with you—these are core aspects of what makes Michelman special. We appreciate your constructive feedback regarding leadership styles and career progression. We recognize that leadership development and creating clear growth opportunities are essential for a thriving workplace. Our team is actively working on initiatives to strengthen leadership capabilities and explore ways to provide more career development paths within our organization. Thank you again for your insights and contributions. Your feedback helps us continue to improve and ensure Michelman remains a great place to work.
3.0
Feb 18, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

My immediate team consists of some of the best people I could ever ask to work with. Manager and director make me feel seen.

Cons

Despite having a great team, the opportunity for growth is low to non-existant. While my role is a supportive one, we are still essential to the day-to-day of the business to keep things operating smoothly and I don't feel that is recognized outside of the department beyond a few kind words here and there. Since working here (5+years) I have seen maybe two promotions that were driven by actual career growth rather than forced reorganization due to departures or other restructuring. Whenever I've brought up what growth looks like in my role here and what I can do to achieve it, my manager will consistently go to bat for me. But is always met with push back from the business for one reason or another. There has also been a revolving door of positions within the department. And now we are operating with what feels like a bare bones group while lumping multiple job roles on to every member of the team, leading to burnout. At this point the team is stays together simply because we enjoy our immediate coworkers.

avatar
Michelman Response
2mo
Thank you for sharing your experience and for your many years of dedication. We’re pleased to hear that your team and leadership have provided strong support. We also acknowledge the concerns raised around career growth, recognition, and department capacity, including the impact of turnover and increased workloads. These are areas we are actively working to improve, and feedback like yours helps guide our focus on sustainable staffing, clearer development paths, and long‑term engagement. We appreciate your candid perspective and continued commitment to Michelman.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All