Disappointing Experience—Toxic Culture, Poor Leadership - Anonymous Employee Counterpart Employee Review

1.0
Jul 7, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Fully remote work environment. Some smart, talented individuals across teams who try their best despite the circumstances.

Cons

Toxic work culture: Despite being fully remote, the environment is tense, unsupportive, and driven by poor leadership decisions. Leadership issues: Promotions are given to individuals who lack the experience or capability to lead effectively, while real talent is overlooked or let go. CEO and executive team are disengaged: There is little regard for employee well-being, growth, or retention. Morale is consistently low. Compensation and benefits: Pay is below market value, especially given the heavy workloads and expectations. Benefits are mediocre at best. Lack of industry knowledge: A surprising number of employees, including in leadership roles, have little to no understanding of the insurance space—despite this being an insurance company. This has created minimal collaboration or respect for subject matter expertise.

avatar
Counterpart Response
8mo
We’re sorry to hear that your experience at Counterpart felt challenging. We recognize that navigating growth, remote work, and evolving team dynamics can be complex, and we know there’s always room to improve. We appreciate your feedback and remain committed to building a culture rooted in clarity, accountability, and collaboration. Thank you for taking the time to share your perspective.

Explore other reviews about Counterpart

5.0
May 11, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The team is sharp - and the right people are in the right places. You're working alongside people who actually understand insurance and tech. Some of the brightest minds in each industry have converged here. Real ownership of your work. This isn't a place where you're a cog. You see the direct impact of what you do on the product and the business on the monthly, weekly and even daily. Leadership is accessible and genuinely open to ideas. The distance between "I have a thought" and "let's try it" is incredibly short. That's refreshing in an industry where you are frequently hit with the "that's not how we do it here" mentality. The mission makes sense. Professional liability insurance is overdue for modernization, and Counterpart is actually doing it rather than just pitching a deck about it. Good work-life balance for the industry. You're trusted to manage your own time like an adult. We have a work from anywhere philosophy, taking remote work to a new level. There is no micro-managing. People trust each other to do the work, and we do, on person-by-person terms.

Cons

Like any growing company priorities can evolve quickly, but that keeps the work dynamic and means you're always close to what matters most to the business.

5.0
May 5, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The culture here is genuinely great! It's fast-paced and people are driven, but everyone is also super collaborative and willing to help each other out. You have full ownership over your work and while competitive, it never feels cutthroat. Being fully remote is a huge plus, and it actually works well because the company has built real systems help you connect with your teammates. You're trusted to manage your own time and get things done without anyone breathing down your neck. Leadership is transparent and approachable, which makes a big difference. Benefits are solid, work-life balance is real, and there are actual opportunities to grow your career if you put in the effort.

Cons

The only downside of being fully remote is the lack of in-person connection; spontaneous conversations and team bonding just don't happen naturally. That said, it's a pretty minor gripe and honestly comes with the territory when remote work is the trade-off. It's also a very entrepreneurial, self-driven environment, so if you need a lot of structure or hand-holding to stay motivated, this probably isn't the right fit.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All